A Navi Mumbai couple successfully sued an airline for charging ₹7,200 for adjacent seat reservations, a practice deemed an unfair trade practice. The Maharashtra State Consumer Disputes Redressal Commission upheld a lower court’s order, stating the airline used a ‘dark pattern’ by withholding information about available free seats, misleading passengers into paying extra.
Navigating the Skies (and Seat Selection): When Premium Isn’t Always Better
Ever feel like airlines are speaking a different language? Between baggage fees, legroom debates, and the mysterious algorithms determining ticket prices, air travel can sometimes feel less like soaring through the clouds and more like navigating a minefield.
Recently, an elderly couple’s experience highlighted a particularly frustrating issue: being charged extra for premium seats when free, standard options were actually available. It’s a scenario many travelers might unknowingly find themselves in, prompting the question: are airlines playing fair with seat selection?
The Case of the Unnecessary Upgrade
This particular story revolves around a couple flying with a major Indian airline. They booked their tickets well in advance and, wanting to ensure comfortable seating, opted for what they believed were premium seats. The catch? Upon boarding, they discovered that standard, non-premium seats were readily available – and remained so throughout the flight. Feeling misled, the couple filed a complaint, arguing that they were unfairly charged for a service they didn’t need and that the airline had essentially misrepresented their seating options.
And here’s the kicker: they won. The consumer court ruled in their favor, ordering the airline to compensate them for the unnecessary charge and for the distress caused. This victory, though specific to this case, raises broader implications for air travelers everywhere.
What This Ruling Means for You: Understanding Airline Seat Selection
This ruling isn’t just a win for this particular couple; it serves as a crucial reminder for all passengers to be vigilant and informed when it comes to airline seat selection. Here’s what you should keep in mind:
* Know Your Rights: Familiarize yourself with the airline’s seat selection policy. Understand the difference between standard seats, premium seats, and any associated fees. This information is usually available on the airline’s website, but it’s worth digging for it.
* Don’t Be Afraid to Ask: When booking, specifically inquire about the availability of standard seats. Don’t assume that the seats offered first are your only options. If booking online, carefully review the seat map and look for unassigned seats.
* Take a Screenshot: If you’re offered a seat at a certain price, and it seems suspiciously high, document it. Capture a screenshot of the seat map showing available standard seats alongside the “premium” options. This can be valuable evidence if you need to dispute a charge later.
* Check in Early (and Often): The earlier you check in, the more likely you are to have a wider selection of seats, including standard options. Even if you’ve already selected a seat, check back periodically before your flight. Seats can open up as other passengers change their plans or as the airline adjusts its seating configuration.
* Speak Up: If you believe you’ve been unfairly charged for a premium seat when standard seats were available, don’t hesitate to file a complaint with the airline and, if necessary, with the appropriate consumer protection agency.

The Bigger Picture: Transparency and Fair Practices
This case underscores the importance of transparency in the airline industry. Airlines have a responsibility to provide clear and accurate information about seat options and associated fees. They shouldn’t be incentivized to push premium seats when standard seats are readily available. After all, air travel is stressful enough without adding unnecessary confusion and financial burdens.
Airlines could improve by implementing clearer online booking interfaces, offering real-time updates on seat availability, and providing better training to customer service representatives on how to address seating inquiries.
For further reading about navigating travel challenges, see our article on [lost luggage compensation](internal-link-to-lost-luggage-article).
Final Thoughts: Flying Smarter
The elderly couple’s victory serves as an important reminder: passengers have rights, and airlines need to uphold fair business practices. By staying informed, being proactive, and speaking up when necessary, we can all contribute to a more transparent and passenger-friendly flying experience. This situation highlights the need for passengers to be extra cautious with airline seat selection to avoid unnecessary costs.




